Spot repair at the failure
Fits when: A single discrete defect on a line that is otherwise sound — one joint, one puncture, one fitting.
Trade-off: The smallest and least invasive route. It relies on the rest of the line being in good condition, which is only a safe assumption when the material and age support it.
Reroute the affected run
Fits when: The failure sits under a slab, a tiled floor, or anything else expensive to open, and there is a practical path through walls or attic instead.
Trade-off: Avoids breaking concrete altogether. It uses more pipe and leaves the old section abandoned in place, which is normal practice rather than a compromise.
Open the floor over the marked spot
Fits when: Access is straightforward, or a reroute is impractical for that particular run.
Trade-off: Direct and durable. The cost sits in the access and the reinstatement of the floor rather than in the plumbing itself.
Replace the section or repipe
Fits when: Repeat failures on the same lines, or a pipe material that is failing by age along its length rather than at one point.
Trade-off: The largest job, and the only one that ends the pattern. It is worth raising honestly on a second or third failure, and worth arguing against on a first.