Spot repair
Fits when: One confirmed failure point, on a line that is otherwise sound for its age and material.
Trade-off: The smallest opening, the smallest bill, and it assumes the rest of the line will hold — a reasonable assumption on a younger line, a weaker one on an aging galvanized or clay run with a history.
Reroute around the failure
Fits when: The failure sits under something expensive or disruptive to open — a driveway, a finished walkway, mature landscaping.
Trade-off: Avoids breaking the surface above the old line entirely, at the cost of new pipe and an abandoned section left in place, which is standard practice and not itself a problem.
Open and repair the joint or fitting directly
Fits when: Access is straightforward and the failure is clearly at a joint or fitting rather than through the pipe wall.
Trade-off: Direct and often the fastest of the three where it applies — most of the cost sits in the excavation and the making-good, not the fitting itself.